Diary of River Song 4


Time In A Bottle By Matt Fitton and Emma Reeves

Terrible. This story gives us good ideas, like a world without time, and then does nothing with them. No, this one’s real cardinal sin is being one of the most boring listens produced by Big Finish. It’s that bad.
Hello Sweetie: River at least doesn’t seem as bored with the script as I am. 
Overall: Despite introducing some okay side characters/companions for River, it introduces some crap villains called the Discordia which plague this box set. 4/10

Kings Of Infinite Space By Donald McLeary

A semi boring script with a fantastic ending, this is an attempt to recreate ‘The Chase’ on audio, not even one of the best Hartnell stories. Set Four is plagued by these characters, and is more arc based than any other set in the series, to it’s own downfall. We visit like six different alien world's, none of which feel alien or make an impression, and it’s kind of not that great. I also like the Hamlet reference of a title. Just thought I’d mention that. …god I’m a nerd. 
Hello Sweetie: Alex Kingston pulls double duty as a weird hologram thing and River, and it’s great. Thank you, next. As mentioned before, River’s manipulation of the Discordia into a semi-victory against an impossible enemy is the stories highlights. 
Overall: I’ll talk about the Discordia to wrap this up, because they’re kind of stupid. Devils that alter time to always win, except when they actually don’t. That’s what they are. They miss opportunities to win really easily constantly, and minus the last story of the set where Tom Baker realizes you need to beat them really quickly and efficiently, there isn’t a single situation where you don’t feel like “wait those guys could win all they have to do is <INSERT THING HERE>.” One of the better stories in this set, this one is mostly terrible, but that ending: 8/10, Five Points Of Which Are For The Ending, So Take A Guess 

Whodunnit by Matt Fitton

My personal pick for Worst Big Finish Story, there’s so much to unpack in Whodunnit, as it fails on every level you could possibly imagine, except maybe sound design, but even there the Discordia voices are terrible. Yep, halfway through the story, the Discordia are just shoehorned in, and that’s only one of the problems. Whodunnit is beyond abysmal in every single quality I can think of, and I could only listen in morbid fascination of what thing it would get wrong next: Whodunnit has a fantastic central concept, which is weighed down by every single dang thing it does with it:
An Agatha Christie Mystery, where every single suspect is a random stereotype of a famous fictional detective, from Poirot, to Scooby Doo. Then, it randomly decides to become a celebrity historical where Franz Kafka is in it, and the House than begins to sort of Chimes Of Midnight all over the place (you know without being good) and there’s something in the attic, but wait, we never see that substantially, and then the Discordia show up, and can you begin to see the problems with it? It tries so hard to be a Robert Shearman script with a weird atmosphere and characters in a surreal location, without having any of it work. It thinks it’s so much more clever than it actually is. And then it has the audacity to pull an “it was all a dream” ending. 
Do not, I repeat, do not listen to this one. The only thing it introduces is Dante, Who is a replacement for Melak. That’s all you need to know. Please. Just, Go Away. 
Go Away! -1/10 Yes it is that terrible shut up shut up

Someone I Once Knew By John Dorney 

Someone I Once Knew has the audacity to be a fantastic story in the worst box set Big Finish has ever produced, and is legitimately a 10/10 story, so I can’t even say River 4 is the worst box set because someone will say “Oh, what about Someone I Once Knew?” And then I have to sigh and concede to them, that yes, Someone I Once Knew is bloody amazing, and then I go back to cracking pieces out of my Whodunnit CD case. (No, I wouldn’t do that, that was a joke)
Hello Sweetie: Alex Kingston is phenomenal, and yes, this story is very good ok 
Alternate Timeline Tom Baker: Everything that alternate timeline Tom Baker does with his performance to make him recognizably four but so very different and affectionate and everything is beautiful okay don’t message me
Overall: Someone I Once Knew Is So Good that it sort of begins to make up for how bad the rest of River 4 is, I mean come on, how good do you have to be to do that 10/10

 UPDATE:
I did a massive set relisten. River 4 really needs to be revisited, but until then:


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Cobwebs

Image
  Cobwebs by Jonathan Morris Now stop me if you've heard this one before...  The Doctor and Companions arrive in Location X where they discover evidence that something bad is going to happen in the future (i.e. their deaths, the TARDIS not working, etc) and have to fudge the rules of time so they live. It's a Doctor Who stalwart, I should think, I can't count how many stories I've done with it, but the Fires of Vulcan and the entirety of Matt Smith series 6 come readily to mind - and quite frankly, Cobwebs is no exception. It's a complicated time puzzle of a story that will never really surprise you (I figured out the twist a solid hour before it happened.) The story's chief selling point is that for the first time ever since like Mawdwyn Undead and Terminus for two seconds, Tegan, Nyssa, and Turlough are in the TARDIS together. It's other chief selling point is Tegan is in it - this was her second Big Finish audio ever, and she had previously said she would
Read more

Torchwood: Aliens Among Us 2

Image
  Love Rat by Christopher Cooper Trust Big Finish to remake Day One, and not only make it good, but also make it somewhat heartbreaking. Of course, Day One is a terrible and horny bit of TV, and Love Rat is also sort of that way, but it makes up for it (in my book) by dealing with the aftereffects of what this kind of story would actually do to the team. Jack's actions in this episode, although prompted by the parasite, aren't even out of character, and the way he seduces Tyler and Ng and the fallout of that is dealt with in a surprisingly mature and emotional manner. Unlike Day One, which strives to be mature, Love Rat is actually mature, and the Gwen and Ng arc is actually a gutpunch to hear, especially the final few scenes with Rhys, as throughout this series, Ng has taken over Gwen's life and utterly ruined it. It's amazing what Eve Myles can do with just a few words, the emotion she can convey that this isn't what she wants, how horrified she is at not being in
Read more

NCJDDAS: Dark Page

Image
NCJDDAS: Dark Page Cover by Arbrax  This episode of the NOW CANON Judi Dench Doctor adventures was Inspired by Robert Shearman listing a brilliant idea for a short story that wouldn’t work in Doctor Who. I say utter Rubbish. I’m taking that story and writing it in Who. Fight me. It also helps that I haven’t read the story he wrote that I’m utilizing, making this even more of a simple writing prompt thing. Featuring The Twenty Second Doctor, Elizabeth Olsen, as created by Arbrax Chapter One In the town of Broughstershire, at 5:27 AM, the postman came by every house in the neighborhood and gave every single person a letter.  The letter was different for each person. For instance, Mr. Layton got a letter that said May 5, 2027, and below that, in slightly aggressive font, Gangrene. Mrs Curbishley got a letter that said June 18, 2053, Car Crash, and Little Timmy got a letter that said October 9th, 2081, Natural Causes. Of course, these are merely examples, those people don't exist, But
Read more

(MAIN RANGE): Dinnertime Part One

Image
MAIN RANGE: Dinnertime Part One This Story Stars Judi Dench as The Twenty Sixth Doctor and David Tennant as The Tenth Featuring Danny Devito as Danny Devito and John Simm as The Master This Story Takes Place Between A Storm Is A Comin and The Countryfile Conundrum Chapter One "It is said that in the final days of planet earth, everyone had bad dreams. To the west...of the...north... of this world...everyone did...gather? What even is that sentence- um, Sorry, Ah, here we are. IN THE CELEBRATION, of a Pagan rite to banish the cold and the Dark. Each and everyone of those people had nightmares of the pretty mild (for the human race) terror to come (I mean, I think the Dalek invasion was way worse). Everyone except Fred. There's nothing special about Fred, he's not really important to the story, but all the same, he had a dream about shopping, and it was rather average. Okay, so, to sum up. Everyone had bad dreams on Earth, except Fred. They all forgot...Except for one."
Read more

Ninth Doctor Adventures: Ravagers

Image
  The Ninth Doctor Adventures: Ravagers Ravagers is such a weird choice to start the Ninth Doctor Adventures with because in terms of plot, this really feels like an Eleventh Doctor story. It’s convoluted and “timey wimey” and quite possibly disorienting for newcomers. In fact, no, it seems definitely disorienting for newcomers. You think a River Song flow chart was required? Nahh, A Ninth Doctor Ravagers flowchart is required, man. As an audio fanatic, it was quite confusing, and well, perhaps indicative of NuWho Three-Parters, because like most of them, it borders on the shit. And one would expect, me, as not really the worlds hugest Ninth Doctor fan, that I’d hate it, right? Nope! I love it. Really do, I mean, it’s not perfect (first releases for Doctors never are: Sirens of Time, Destination: Nerva and Only the Monstrous are all trash, and Technophobia is just okay) But on the whole, I felt it was a consistent set and the quality never really went up or down much in either directio
Read more